With over 2m pending cases in courts, Justice Shah warns of eroding public trust over delays

ISLAMABAD(National times)- The Supreme Court (SC) has cautioned that delays in adjudicating cases at any level of the justice system erode public confidence, undermine the rule of law and disproportionately harm the weak and vulnerable who cannot afford prolonged litigation, The News reported on Saturday. A two-member bench, comprising Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah and Justice Ayesha Malik, made the observations in a four-page judgment dismissing a petition by Abdul Salam Khan against a Peshawar High Court verdict in a property auction case. The court noted the matter had been pending for 14 years — 10 of them in the high court — before reaching the Supreme Court in 2022, where it was taken up in 2025. In the four-page verdict, Justice Shah pointed out the said case pending before the PHC for 10 years and said the SC could not “remain indifferent to the systemic malaise of delay in the adjudication of cases”. “It is beyond cavil that delay in adjudicating cases by the courts at any tier of the justice system corrodes public confidence in the judiciary, undermines the rule of law, and disproportionately harms the weak and vulnerable who cannot afford the cost of prolonged litigation. “Delay in adjudication carries severe macroeconomic and societal consequences: it deters investment, renders contracts illusory, and weakens the institutional legitimacy of the judiciary,” Justice Shah warned. Highlighting that over 2.2 million cases were currently pending before courts across Pakistan, including approximately 55,941 cases before the SC alone, the judge remarked that “justice delayed is not merely justice denied; it is often justice extinguished”. Terming the issue as a matter of institutional policy and constitutional responsibility, Justice Shah urged that the SC “must urgently transition toward a modern, responsive, and intelligent case management framework”. “Such a system must, at a minimum, ensure: the early fixation of cases on a non-discriminatory basis; the elimination of ‘queue-jumping’ and preferential scheduling; the prioritisation of matters involving constitutional, economic, or national importance without compromising the timely resolution of individual claims; the implementation of age-tracking protocols to automatically identify dormant cases; and the judicious use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools to assist in scheduling and triage while preserving the sanctity of judicial discretion,” the judge noted.



Latest News
Gandapur vows no let-up in relief efforts as PMD warns of more intense rains in KP
Journalist Khawar Hussain found dead in car with gunshot wound to head
Over 340 dead as rescue operations continue across northern Pakistan
‘God made me this country’s guardian’: COAS Asim Munir dismisses change rumours
Community should not suffer for individual terrorist acts: DG ISPR
With over 2m pending cases in courts, Justice Shah warns of eroding public trust over delays
IMF stresses reforms for bolstering anti-money laundering legislation
Pakistan, US to further adjust trade, investment deals




Multi Media   
Embassy of Pakistan 🇵🇰 in Brussels || Quarterly Recap of Activities, Engagements & Outreach
 Multi Media
DPM Dar sends Trump peace prize nomination to Nobel Committee
 Multi Media
Pak Navy Chief Visits Foreign Ships Participating in Ninth Multinational Naval Exercise Aman | ISPR
 Multi Media
PM Shehbaz Sharif Addresses | Breathe Pakistan Global Climate Conference I 07-02-2025
 Multi Media
COAS visited Muzaffarabad, where he paid homage to the sacrifices of the martyrs.| ISPR